[volunteers] registrant changes - right thing
Rick Moen
rick at linuxmafia.com
Fri Oct 20 10:13:43 PDT 2006
Quoting Heather Stern (star at starshine.org):
> Actually, I considered that, but expected some sort of snarl about trying
> to hide passwords.
Yeah, what can you do?
> I figured the honorable route was to fulfill my promise earlier in
> this reluctant sequence (you remember when I said I didn't really want
> to be in the middle of it all? Well, guess what: now you know why)
> and give the password to the "many" - which quite frankly, isn't very
> many - and let the President, who's been taking an active role, do the
> active thing.
>
> I see that neither route would have been taken as a right answer, so I'm
> just stuck.
>
> The president has never bothered to give me his phone number, or that would
> have been how it was done, and the possibility exists that none of you would
> have seen any of this mail.
Hmm, that's a problem.
I think I'd have tried the contact telephone number(s) for his domain of
record (sigkill.com). If that didn't work, I'd have posted here, CCing
Paul's e-mail address at sigkill.com, the fact that you're trying to
reach him to convey the domain password, that you'd appreciate a
call at (XXX) XXX-XXXX within 48 hours, and that absent a call you'll
default to posting it here in two days and then trust to the right
parties to change it appropriately.
> Whether that would have been a likable answer either is... well, I guess I
> don't get to win, now do I?
My agreeing with Paul that it was a little inept wasn't exactly reading
you any form of riot act; it just wasn't very good password handling,
and we should try to avoid the perceived necessity going forward. That
was the sum total of what I meant (that along with knocking apart Paul
Reed's you-can't-call-A-inept-without-calling-B-inept
excuse-making ploy).
> Not for lack of me clicking the approve link in my side of the mail,
> however. I did, in fact, approve the transaction.
>
> Joker cancels requests that don't get confirmed by both sides of the
> transaction. It's their policy to prevent domains from being sent into
> limbo where their mail can't be retrieved.
These are very important points. Please note, people: Heather _did_
issue the approval that generated the confirmation number. Paul just
didn't bother to carry out his follow-up step as required by registrar
procedure.
Paul dropped the ball, there. (If Paul wants to cry out that I'm
picking on him and being mean, that's his cue. Go for it, guy.)
> I asked someone among you souls that do the DNS parts to create a CORG-
> entry for yourself so I could move at least one of the "magic 3" addresses
> for the .Org entry over to that; no response yet, but hey, I can ask again.
This was very definitely not within my authority or responsibilities at
the time. I'll be doing it now in order to adjust the Technical Contact
mailbox address. (Note to readers: This follows my in-person
discussion of the idea with Heather last night, making sure I know
what's entailed, and making sure Heather agrees it's desirable.)
> * renewal pains: they accept money from absolutely anyone to renew a
> domain. Just throw money. No affect on ownership.
> That means any SVLUG member can Do That Right Thing.
This is a major plus. (Heather mentioned this to me last night, too.)
More information about the volunteers
mailing list