[svlug] Expectations for Windows XP and Linux
Rick Moen
rick at linuxmafia.com
Mon Jul 24 16:18:17 PDT 2006
Quoting Tom Pilot (hman_120 at yahoo.com):
> So to summarize (correct me if wrong): 1. wifi is not as well
> supported as lan nics because manufacturers dont provide required spec
> info
It's not _quite_ that simple, but that's a big part of it.
> 2. manufacturers are not motivated to provide this info becuase unlike
> lan nics, wifi cards are not used in servers and there arent enough
> desktop users to make it worthwhile
They're also reportedly wary of overstepping FCC regulations about
consumer access to controls on regulated radio-transmitting devices.
Long story. An engineer who works for an Atheros business partner
recently monopolised a bunch of my time about this in private e-mail,
and I ran out of time to pursue the discussion: Suffice it to say,
there is some room for debate about the extent to which this justifies
affected firms' refusal to cooperate with the open source community.
When I have time, I intend to write up a summary with references of the
known underlying facts and arguments made by people.
Micro-rant: This will compensate for companies making a lazy handwave
at the problem, saying "We can't do open source; FCC won't let us", not
bothering to cite particular Part 6 CFR sections they think apply let
alone a rulemaking docket or Report and Order, and then acting all
surprised when the open source community expresses doubt.
> 3. Due to 1 and 2, the only option is to reverse engineer, which takes
> a s**load of time
Well, that depends on a number of things including what coders feel a
need to scratch their own iteches. Statements from J. Random User that
"Linux needs [foo]" aren't considered a motivator, to put it mildly, and
will garner mostly polite, quiet rolling of eyes and moving on to the
next posting. Basically, that and $1.50 will get you a ride on Muni.
> Ok so now i will make the following experiment: I will take a wifi
> card that is supported by linux based on (Rick's?) compatability list
> - I.E. this will be a card that has already been reverse engineered?.
> I will then install it on my XP machine and then on my Ubuntu machine
> and report my experience to the group
Do you expect us to care?
It may be just an unfortunate coincidence, but you come across to me as
a LUG newcomer who's attempting to troll. Speaking for myself, I'll very
often go to extraordinary lengths to help newcomers who take the time to
describe a specific problem and ask help. Those who come out of nowhere
to pick a fight or demand that the Linux community prove something get
served last, if at all.
More information about the svlug
mailing list