[svlug] Expectations for Windows XP and Linux

Walt Reed svlug at linuxguy.com
Mon Jul 24 12:54:03 PDT 2006


Out of order and broken quoting fixed... (Please configure your mail
client correctly.)

On Mon, Jul 24, 2006 at 12:32:50PM -0700, Tom Pilot said:
> Rick Moen <rick at linuxmafia.com> wrote:
>   Quoting Tom Pilot (hman_120 at yahoo.com):
> 
>>> Maybe instead of constantly slamming windows, energy would be better
>>> spent in making Linux as 802.11b/g friendly as windows is? Of the 2
>>> laptops that I have, every time I put windows on them, my wifi cards
>>> work almost instantly. As soon I install Linux I need to spend 5 hours
>>> on each to get wifi to work.
>> 
>> It's easy to make Linux easy to use on the general run of wifi cards.
>> All you have to do is give up on open source, and buy a distribution
>> that includes a raft of proprietary drivers.
>> 
>> Of course, most Linux distributions' maintainers refuse to buy into that
>> trap. Thus, if you've selected your hardware poorly, you may end up
>> feeling compelled to retrofit proprietary workarounds (madwifi,
>> ndiswrapper, etc.).
>> 
>>> so quit ya bitchin about windows and just like you learn to imitate
>>> the windows UI in kde and gnome, start imitating the WIFI support
>>> windows has!
>> 
>> Proprietary junk, no-reverse-engineering clauses, etc.? No thanks, Tom.
>> No going there.

> In the beginning (6 years ago?) support for regular cat5 lan was
> difficult, and installing an ethernet card was hard and tedious .
> today the process is fully automated, when installing pretty much any
> linux distro. So why cant we get to this stage with wifi hardware...
> wifi hardware and ethernet hardware is just as proprietory, etc. I

Ah - but there is a difference. LAN hardware is needed for servers. Wifi
is not. Wifi is 99% laptops which is probably the smallest corporate
installed base of Linux.

HP and IBM have a huge vested interest in making sure their servers are
well supported by Linux due to the demands of enterprise IT where
corporate adoption of Linux is huge. The corporate demand for Linux
desktops has not reached the levels needed to force manufacturers to
cooperate.

> think the linux community is just slow to respond to hardware
> innovations, or at least not as fast as Microsoft is able to.  Lets

Microsoft doesn't respond. Hardware manufacturers do. I think that's the
part you are missing here.

> review this now and try to really solve the problem starting with this
> basic question:
>    
>   - What does microsoft have that allows it to have so much better wifi support in its OS?

A near monopoly on the desktop which forces hardware manufacturers to
write drivers for their platform. The MFR's BEG MS to include their
drivers and pay big bucks to get them "Microsoft certified and signed".
It really is that simple.

It's not the Linux community you have to convince. It's the hardware
manufacturers (which include the chip vendors almost more than the card
vendors.)




More information about the svlug mailing list