[svlug] USB Pen drives reliable?

Scott Hess scott.hess at gmail.com
Thu Apr 28 10:27:11 PDT 2005


On 4/28/05, steve <steve at itsage.com> wrote:
> John Conover wrote:
> > Are USB pen drives reliable?
> >
> > I just lost one that is less than a half year old. Is this typical?
> 
> I would think it depends on the number of writes you've done to the key.
> Its a solid state device, so I'd guess it would be thousands (100's of
> thousands?) writes.  But I find it hard to believe you've done enough
> writes to wear it out in 6 months?

It's almost (but not quite) inconceivable that you could manage the
number of writes necessary.  Most flash (I mean the chips themselves)
can bear 100k writes or 1M writes, and those are probably somewhat
conservative.  Furthermore, most flash controllers do some amount of
wear-levelling, so the even many writes to a single logical sector
don't go to a single physical sector.

That said, you might have been lucky.  A super-cheap device might have
chips only rated for 100k writes, and the controller might not do any
wear-levelling, and ext3 might spend a lot of time thrashing the
journal.  Even then, you probably would have to leave it mounted
almost continuously and be pretty active on it, which doesn't really
fit the expectations for USB pen drives.

My guess is something physical.  You'll probably pass the number of
insertions the device is rated for before passing the number of writes
it's rated for.  If you took it between your work and home machines
every day for six months, that's something like 240 insertions.  Maybe
something has flexed enough to break a connection somewhere.

-scott




More information about the svlug mailing list