[Smaug] Is SourceForge the right place for SMAUG ?

Rick Moen rick@linuxmafia.com
Mon Jan 28 19:31:01 2002


OK, so Raphael complained off-list about lots of things, which we'll
not air here.  But he wanted some specific response -- which he either
wants to be specifically from me or specifically not from me (it was
unclear <shrug>) -- on this:

> ...could you please point me to something related to the claim that VA
> Linux "annexed" the SourceForge contributors individual rights on
> their code ?

The bit just before that, that I might as well do this because I have a 
lot of time on my hands, was... really annoying.  But I regret having 
responded with short temper for that reason.

And I'll take a shot at the quoted bit, even though someone may
object to that, too:


The question concerned Loïc Dachary's anecdote about a request from 
SourceForge.net management.  Dachary says he's made some unspecified
code contributions to some unspecified codebase that's used in
SourceForge.net.  Maybe the alexandria package.  

So, it sounds like, according to Dachary, somebody in SourceForge.net
management asked him (twice) if he'd be willing to assign his copyright
for that code with no strings attached.  And he said no.  And Dachary
finds all this sinister.

And I'd love to be able to answer Raphael's question about this, from 
whatever I've heard on the Net -- but I don't know what's being asked,
and I can't remember anything else relevant to the matter.


Raphael has problems with my earlier post that "Since Smaug more or less
decided it wanted to shed its former acronym expansion, and make Smaug
be just a name standing for nothing in particular, the name's been
re-rendered into uppers-and-lowers everywhere practical, and the
subtitle Santa Cruz Microsoft Alternative User Group expunged from the
PNG logo."  Raphael objects that this wasn't voted.  Fair 'nough.

My summary was based on what Karsten wrote here after the last meeting:

   Much was discussed about why we call ourselves SMAUG and why have a
   different domain name.  No vote was taken, but there seemed to be some
   consensus at the table:

   o Giving breathing time to even saying the word Microsoft seemed odious
     for everyone, so why have it be in our title?
   o However, we could spend gobs of time making a decision, and then we
     would have to get new branding and everything.
   o Therefore, let's take the path of least resistance and call ourselvs
     Smaug where means nothing in particular.

Now, I have no idea what requires a "vote", who has to be there, what
constitutes a quorum, etc.  As I said, I understood that to be what the 
group more-or-less decided, and that's why I went through all that work
on the Web site.  And on the mailing list's settings.

One of the nice things about having the Web site under version control
is that it's dead-simple to reverse that and erase any part of my work
considered undesirable.  I've encouraged Raphael to revert or alter the
site as he considers needed.  And ditto for anyone else.  The project
pages now include some how-to documentation I wrote, to help.  (Change
or delete that too, if you wish.)