[SMAUG] Linux-friendly ISP
Karsten Wade
phig@phig.org
Wed Jan 9 14:01:01 2002
Interesting carry over, and I am going to mention stuff that was discussed
during the meeting on Monday 7 January.
On Wed, 9 Jan 2002, David Correa wrote:
> > Sonic.net (http://www.sonic.net/)
> Hi,
>
> I am looking at http://www.sonic.net/sales/index.shtml
> and they call their aDSL "Pacific Bell ADSL"
>
> I am not sure that anyone can avoid Pacific Bell in
> this area if they want to connect to the Internet.
> (cable tv is not available here)
This is true, however there is more complexity. Because the RBOC
(Regional Bell Operating Company like SBC) owns the copper, they have to
provide any CLEC (Competitive Local Exchange Carrier) with access.
However, most of the CLECs have gone bankrupt.
The secondary carriers like sonic.net and speakeasy.net have some
advantages in purchasing DSL in bulk from SBC:
- Their prices are cheaper (right now, but not true two years ago)
- They can offer static IPs for cheaper accounts (the basic service), and
more IPs if they feel like it, or charge for it, or whatever
- Better ancillary Web services (like email addys with the account, Web
space on their servers (SBC is 5 MB, barely enough to put up the Ballmer
monkeyboy video)
- And, of course, personalized customer support (see below)
> One problem I see, is the potential of being stuck in the
> middle, while the ISP blames Pac Bell and vice versa for
> problems in the line. The way I have this now Pac Bell
> (SBC) can only blame themselves for troubles in the circuit.
> Not that they really care about that.
One point made at the meeting was that the secondary providers can act as
a single point of contact, using their clout to ferret out SBC issues that
might be ignored for a single or small group of users (such as poorly
written DNS records, etc.).
> > In terms of the "linux Friendly" attitude, that is
probably > great, but I have never needed support from an ISP to set
> up my Internet connection(s). All I really need is a circuit
> that works 24/7 with out me having to reboot the aDSL modem.
Some DSL providers act as if Linux users carry the plague. Similar to how
cable providers specify that you can't "run a server", I have heard of
people who call tech support for _anything_ (like their modem needing to
be reset) being told that because the user is running Linux, the provider
can't provide technical assistance.
> One thing that I like from them (sonic.net) is that they are
> hooked to the mbone. One thing that I do not like is that they
> have a long distance # (area code 707) for technical support.
> I did try it, and I was put on hold, I hanged up after a 5 minutes
> wait. Not that SBC answers faster, but at least is
> an 800 number.
I don't know about the 800 number thing, but one item I like about the
smaller carriers is that they have the option of setting up such
additional types of connectivity (mbone) outside of their contracts for
bandwidth and DSL provisioning. For example, speakeasy.net uses(used?)
Covad for their DSL provider (Covad is a CLEC using the copper of RBOCs
such as PacBell/SBC, BellAtlantic/Verizon, etc.). When Covad filed for
chapter whatever bankruptcy, speakeasy.net went on record with their
recovery plans in the case of a disaster similar to AT&T cable recently.
They guarantee service restore within 24 hours or something amazing like
that, and this seems to be inline with their general customer service
philosophy as I have heard of it.
> > BTW, I am not promoting SBC, I will go on record here
with > the (true) statement "SBC Service Sucks". But I do not see a viable
> alternative for me (my location) now.
Have you tried another provider to see if they can carry you? You seem to
be considering a second DSL line. I want to do something similar, pick up
a second connection from someone like sonic.net for cheap, and use the
single IP to have dual-connecitivity (speed and reliability). I'm
interested in how you propose to handle the routing with BGP4. We can
take that discussion offline if others are bored by it. :) :)
- k'
> > Cheers,
>
> David Correa RHCE CCNA
> http://www.linux-tech.com
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> smaug mailing list
> smaug@lists.svlug.org
> http://lists.svlug.org/lists/listinfo/smaug
> SMAUG home page: http://smaug-web.sourceforge.net/
>
'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`'`
Karsten Wade "As sharp as the leading
karsten@phig.org edge of a ball bearing."
http://phig.org/gpg/ - Dallas Dobro